A mother and her two children haven long been tormented by Haven locals, who have blamed the late father of the family for a recent tragic accident in town — the sinking of a charter boat — ever since it claimed several lives. But when someone comes to harass the family and is literally sent flying from the home — and when another tormentor is attacked by flying objects — Audrey and Nathan begin to suspect that something or someone supernatural has taken control of the house. As Nathan works with Duke to uncover the truth behind the accident that claimed the father, Audrey stays to investigate whether one of the family members might be more “Troubled” than meets the eye.